The Perfect Christmas Pumpkin Pie
Sunday, January 8th, 2012
Not to beat up on The Barefoot Contessa, because her Lemon Yogurt Cake recipe is amazing, as is the Lemon Chicken — a pattern seems to be emerging — but the Pumpkin Pie did not turn out.
But what really didn’t work was the banana. The what? Right, I thought a banana was odd, too. But since I’m trying to stop living on red licorice and Diet Coke alone, I thought, okay, a little fresh fruit couldn’t hurt. But, no. A pumpkin-banana- cream-pudding-pie was not what the Pilgrims ordered.
Generally I make a recipe twice so as to correct any mistakes and add the pie to my Can Do list, but who needs Christmas to be confectionery scrapbook of a failed Thanksgiving?
So where do you go in a situation like this? Back to Zen Master Martha, of course, even if her show on the Hallmark channel did just get canceled. Ratings are their issue, for pie making you can’t beat The Martha Stewart Baking Handbook.
The result — the most seriously flawless Christmas Pumpkin Pie that ever lived. Perfect pumpkin color and texture and incredible, unbelievably rich yet sweetly buoyant flavor that got its non-cloying brightness from ginger instead of cloves. And did I mention the perfect crust? Although I don’t use any salt. (Don’t mention this to Martha).
So thanks, Martha, for the perfect Christmas Pumpkin Pie. Minus the perfect life.










This is perfect for my low-sodium diet!!