victoria@goinglocal-info.com told Penelope, “I need some help with tips for using frozen summer fruits in pie fillings. Most of the recipes I see use fresh fruit but as a gardener with an orchard I have lots of frozen berries, peaches, rhubarb, and other fruits. My friends are split as to how to freeze the fruit for pies (sugar vs no sugar and Fruit Fresh vs no Fruit Fresh) and how to use them in the pies (thaw vs using them frozen). I have tried every method I know of and still get soggy bottom crusts and too much juice in the filling when I use the frozen or thawed fruit. What’s the secret to freezing the fruit and then using it in a pie so that my pie does not end up with a soggy crust?”
Penelope looks at the issue of freezing fresh fruit the same way the Prince looked at Sleeping Beauty when he finally found her in the room at the top of the castle — meaning, whatever was in the potion that put her to sleep would influence what she’d be like when she woke up. So the fewer ingredients there are in the mix when your fruit closes its eyes for the winter, the fewer variables there will be when it returns to its natural state. If your fruit is naked, it will sleep with greater abandon, you’ll do less adjusting for sweetness in the recipe, and the consistency will be more like the berry you knew and loved, and wanted to spend the life of your pie with. So nyet on the sugar or fresheners.
To thaw or not to thaw? Yes, definitely thaw out the fruit. It’s rude not to. Frozen fruit will make your pie runny, and anyway, would you like to wake up and find yourself in the oven? or would you rather be brought slowly and gently to room temperature, properly drained, patted dry, and then added like your old self to a recipe, in which the sugar doesn’t have to be adjusted for some sucrose interloper you’d been gooped-up with for months?
As for soggy bottom prevention: well-drained fruit is the big thing. Then, keep the fruit and the dry, thickening ingredients separate until you’re just about to pile the fruit mixture into the pie crust. Combining the ingredients for the fruit mixture at the very last minute keeps the juices from settling, so the crust gets to set as much as possible as it bakes. In fact, do the same when you’re using fresh fruit.
Romantic note:
The strawberry is actually a member of the Rose family. So if you should meet a man cultivated enough to give you a basket of beautiful strawberries instead of a dozen roses, don’t be insulted. Get dressed up.